Author: JoAnn Mulready-Shick, EdD, RN, CNE
Title: Undergraduate Nursing Program Director
Institution: University of Massachusetts- Boston
This tool may be utilized to evaluate students in the clinical setting. Examples for the first clinical experience and the final clinical experience are included. This tool incorporates beginner level KSAs for all QSEN competencies for the first Clinical Evaluation Tool (#1 Freshmen Level) and incorporates advanced level KSAs for all QSEN competencies for the second Clinical Evaluation Tool (#2 SEnior Level)
These clinical evaluation tools were created from a number of sources. First, to enhance reliability and performance ratings, a variation of the rating scale as published by S.D. Holaday and K. M. Buckley, A Standardized Clinical Evaluation Toolkit: Improving Nursing Education and Practice, was employed. Second, the ANA Standards of Practice criteria for Professional Behaviors. Third, faculty determined the most relevant QSEN competencies to include in clinical evaluation. The tool was piloted in 2009 and minor modifications have been made subsequently based on faculty feedback.
Faculty inter-rater reliability has improved through faculty development sessions and use of role plays of different scenarios for rating clinical performance with each tool. Additional tools for intermediate level courses are also available.